Steve served with Gene in the U.S. Navy during World War 2 and entered the professional wrestling circuit after the war. From 1947 to 1948, Stanlee wrestled under the ring name Paul Stanlee for Georgia Championship Wrestling. He competed against such wrestlers as Tom Mahoney and Bobby Roberts, winning the majority of these matches. Like his brother Gene, Steve took the nickname “Mr. America” for his chiseled physique, bleached his hair blond, and wore dazzling sequined jackets to the ring. Gene and Steve did train together and had a couple of runs as a tag team, but the two generally stayed on separate career paths. Notably, Steve wrestled Lou Thesz for the NWA World Heavyweight Championship on October 27, 1950, two full years before his brother faced Thesz.
After his stint in Georgia, Stanlee competed in Toronto Canada. He worked as a jobber, putting other wrestlers over. In the early 1950s, Stanlee wrestled in the Northeastern USA. Wrestling in New York & New Jersey, he received occasional pushes, challenging for the NWA Crown on several occasions.
Stanlee then traveled to California, where he wrestled in the mid-1950s. He later returned to wrestle for Capitol Wrestling in the New York area in the late 1950s.
Steve didn’t catch on with the public in the same way as Gene did, and as a result never attained the same level of fame. He did have a longer career in the ring, however, and may in fact be the better known brother among fans of 1960s wrestling. While Gene was out of wrestling by the early ’60s, Steve remained active. He wrestled both as a singles competitor and as part of a tag team, “The Stanlee Steamers”, with a kayfabe third “brother”, Bob Stanlee (played by Bob Merrill). Unfortunately, Steve won few high-profile matches either way and is generally regarded to have been a “jobber to the stars” for much of his career. He did, however, win the NWA Ohio Heavyweight Title on July 1, 1961 by defeating Frankie Talaber. He dropped the belt back to Talaber in a rematch later that year. Stanlee also helped train Buddy Bison, who wrestled for Georgia Championship Wrestling for several years.
From 1964 to 1966, Stanlee wrestled for the World Wide Wrestling Federation – WWWF. He lost the majority of his matches, but he did get victories over Arnold Skaaland & Baron Mikel Scicluna in 1965. After leaving the WWWF, Stanlee wrestled in Hawaii, competing in both singles matches and in a tag team with Jim Hady. He then returned to Georgia Championship Wrestling, putting over the other talent in that promotion as well.
Later in life, Steve Stanlee appeared in an interview in the Icons Of Wrestling documentary series. He died in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin on July 2, 2010.